US Court Rejects FDA Appeal on GMO Salmon Approval Documents

Posted on Feb 5 2018 - 11:50pm by Sustainable Pulse

Last week, the U.S. Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals denied the FDA’s latest attempt to hide thousands of pages of key government documents related to the agency’s first-ever approval of genetically engineered (GE) salmon for human consumption. The court’s decision is a big win for public transparency and a firm rejection of the Trump administration’s position that it can unilaterally decide whether to withhold government documents from public and court review.


In 2015, the FDA approved a GE salmon made from the DNA of three different animals: Atlantic salmon, deep water ocean eelpout, and Pacific Chinook salmon. The GE version is intended to grow faster than conventional farmed salmon, reportedly getting to commercial size in half the time.

Even though this is the first time any government in the world has approved a GE animal for commercial sale and consumption, so far the FDA has taken a lackadaisical approach to evaluating the salmon’s potential for harm to wild salmon and the environment. If the GE salmon were to escape, it could threaten wild salmon populations by outcompeting them for scarce resources and habitat, by mating with endangered salmon species, and by introducing new diseases.

If the GE salmon were to escape, it could threaten wild salmon populations by outcompeting them for scarce resources and habitat, by mating with endangered salmon species, and by introducing new diseases

The world’s preeminent experts on GE fish and risk assessment, as well as biologists at U.S. wildlife agencies charged with protecting fish and wildlife, heavily criticized the FDA for failing to evaluate these impacts. But the FDA ignored their concerns, so in March 2016, Earthjustice filed a lawsuit against the agency.

As part of the lawsuit, the FDA is required to compile a record of documents that illuminate the path the agency followed to reach its decision to approve the GE salmon—much like a student is required to show their work for a math problem in middle school.  A complete record is essential in all cases. But it is especially important here because the FDA has so far refused to release most of the documents related to its decision, despite repeated requests for that information from Earthjustice’s diverse set of clients under the Freedom of Information Act.

The public has a right to know how the agency came to this seemingly ill-informed decision, especially because the FDA’s approach will likely serve as a precedent for the assessment of future GE food animals. Withholding that information is illegal because government agencies like the FDA are funded by taxpayer dollars, which means that any records they create, with only limited exceptions, can and should be available to the public and to citizens seeking to hold the government accountable in court.

In January 2017, a U.S. District Court judge agreed, concluding that “the government is wrong to assert that these types of materials…should be excluded” from the record. The FDA is now required to fully complete the record with all relevant documents no later than July 2017. Several months later, the FDA asked the appeals court to override that judge’s decision. In its petition, the administration made a sweeping argument, with severe ramifications for effective court review of government actions—that defendant agencies can determine unilaterally what information to give to courts reviewing their decisions, and do not have to disclose any internal materials, even if the agency considered those materials in its decision. If adopted, this view would have had far-reaching consequences for public review of agency decisions that have major impacts on everyday life.

The FDA is now required to fully complete the record with all relevant documents. The district court is expected to set a deadline after a hearing in late February. In addition to working to ensure the timely completion of that process, Earthjustice will thoroughly review the full basis for the agency’s decisions.

“Our courts provide a level playing field where not even the federal government is above the law,” says Earthjustice attorney Steve Mashuda. “Federal agencies cannot avoid accountability by omitting inconvenient facts and presenting a fictional account of their decisions.”

1 Star2 Stars3 Stars4 Stars5 Stars
(5 votes, average: 5.00 out of 5)
About the Author

Sustainable Pulse is a global news outlet covering sustainable agriculture, GMOs and pesticides.

5 Comments so far. Feel free to join this conversation.

  1. McKenzie Wayne February 6, 2018 at 04:04 - Reply

    Brilliant , these people who basically run rough shod need to be hauled in and made accountable. The world is suffering badly from reckless governments and greedy corporations. Once people realise the food chain is broken , the more of this will be exposed

  2. Sci-reader February 7, 2018 at 23:00 - Reply

    As long as the courts uphold the rule of law then the public can combat secrecy. The will hold until Der Fuhrer replaces all judges with his had picked stooges who will rule for secrecy.

  3. Bill Gates February 8, 2018 at 18:32 - Reply

    Crossing animal kingdoms is NEVER ever a good idea. The FDA wouldn’t know what a Long TERM Safety Study was if it them in the face. The FDA (along with EVER other Alphabet Soup Agency) is a CORRUPT entity that is part of the SWAMP that needs to be reigned in. There are far to many example of CORRUPTION that sadly, even our courts have IGNORED. I’m afraid this is just another illusion within the US Feudal Law System in place. AND it’s got NOTHING to do with TRUMP….he’s just the next PUPPET running our Corrupt GOvernment, just as there’s no difference between a Democrat or Republican….THE”RE ALL PAID SHILLS POISONING THE WORLD & OUR CHILDREN….FACT!! The entire lot are ROTTEN!

    • patz February 16, 2018 at 01:22 - Reply

      hit the nail on the head!

  4. Dede February 22, 2018 at 22:25 - Reply

    The American People are not standing for the Industry collusion with our government, to hide Monsanto’s secrets. When we eat Salmon, we want it WILD and not GMO’d with DNA from other types of fish. Farm raised fish is poopy fish. I will never forget the first time I unawares purchased farm raised catfish and served it to GUESTS! It tasted like poop! This was my famous recipe, received always with raves. I said NEVER AGAIN to farm raised fish.
    Please keep us updated on FDA being forthcoming with all Monsanto’s dirt, their lack of studies and pathological lying.

Leave A Response